The Purple Rose of Cairo (1985)

 The Purple Rose of Cairo

My personal opinion that the best Woody Allen movies are those without Woody Allen just got another confirmation. While “The Purple Rose of Cairo” is undisputably a Woody Allen movie, he is himself absent from the movie and the movie totally works.

We are in New Jersey during the Great Depression where Cecilia (Mia Farrow) is a not very successful waitress, living in a not very successful relationship with the abusive and lazy Monk (Danny Aiello). Cecilia spends her time dreaming of something better and nowhere more so than in the cinema.

Her current favourite movie is a romantic flick called “The Purple Rose of Cairo” and she watches it as often as she can get away with it. One fateful evening something weird happens. The character Tom Baxter (Jeff Daniels), an archaeologist who in the movie will fall in love with a cabaret singer, suddenly turns around and addresses Cecilia directly. He has noticed that she is always there and looking at him and he want to know her. Tom steps out of the movie and leave the cinema with Cecilia.

Unsurprisingly, this gets both very strange and really messy. The movie cannot go on without Tom, leaving the other characters in confusion, the cinema owner does not know if he dares stop the movie and calls the studio in a panic. The studio is at a loss on what to do since this is spreading to other towns and sends the actor behind the Tom Baxter character, Gil Shepherd, to New Jersey to convince Tom to rejoin the movie. Meanwhile, Cecilia and Tom have a most strange affair with Tom realizing that the real world is a lot more complicated than his movie world and Cecilia trying to balance everything going on. This is not getting easier when Gil shows up and seduces her. Now Cecilia has to chose between a fantasy character or a real-life man.

It is very easy to recognize this as a Woody Allen movie. He has projected a lot of his own characters into the Cecilia character, making her a female version of himself. Woody Allen also has a thing for the period between the wars and in many ways “The Purple Rose of Cairo” is a parallel to his later movie “Midnight in Paris”, which incidentally is my favourite Woody Allen movie. While Owen Wilson’s character is being transported back to the 1920’ies, Cecilia is being transported into the world of her movies (in the thirties) and this daydream or surreal experience helps them find out something about themselves and get out of a rut they are stuck in.

The idea of getting in and out of a movie harks back to at least Buster Keaton’s “Sherlock Jr.” and this is an obvious inspiration. A decade or so after “The Purple Rose of Cairo”, this theme was explored again in “The Last Action Hero” with a lot of the same points. This is both a very outlandish theme and one that most people cannot help to have had, watching movies, “what if I could join the movie or maybe these people would show up in real life?”. It takes some juggling to make us suspend our disbelief, but I think Allen is quite successful here, mainly by making it a comedy. By using it for comedic effect, we can laugh off the elements that makes no sense and the craziness becomes part of the fun.

This is where I think “The Purple Rose of Cairo” gets successful, it is genuinely funny. Not in the slapstick manner of “Sherlock Jr.”, but in the messy way an Allen movie gets funny with the critical element that we are spared Allen himself. Mia Farrow and Jeff Daniels are fully able to lift this kind of comedy, and I was having a great time watching this.

I honestly expected this to be a movie I just had to get over with and then it turned out to be one of the best movies so far of 1985. Highly recommended.