Dekalog
For the past month I have been working my way through
“Dekalog”. It is a mountain to climb, ten one-hour movies, each built around
one of the Ten commandments (hence the name). I have known of “Dekalog” for
many years, Kieslowski was one of those hip directors you had to follow if you
were young and cool in the nineties, but I have never had the guts to take on
this massive work. As most such things, when you finally get to it, it is not
as bad or hard as you thought and I was genuinely happy to have watched it.
It makes little sense to describe every episode in detail.
Instead, I will focus on what they have in common, because, yes, as different
as the stories seem, there is a connection, especially in sentiment.
Although each episode is centred around one of the
commandments, it is merely using it as a starting point. The commandments are
very explicit and absolute: Thou shall not... and so on. Translated to real
life things are not so clear cut, but hold dilemmas. You are not allowed to
kill, but does that mean that the state cannot kill the murderer? Most of them
are less direct, though, and lead into tales of people facing dilemmas that do
not have clear moral answers. What may appear as the wrong answer, may in fact
be the right or at least marginally less bad than its opposite.
There is a melancholy tone that is common to all episodes.
You see it in the colours, or lack of colour. The housing block where all
episodes take place is dreary and bleak and almost suck the life out of people.
This is communist Poland of 1988, but even by that standard, the dreariness is
common to all strata of life, from the taxi driver to the surgeon. A man walks
around in his small kitchen, drinks some milk out of a bottle and makes a
simple breakfast and only later you learn he is the manager of a hospital. The
problems people have are of an existential sort. How to choose between two
people or regret of past actions. The people are flawed, but it is (mostly) the
sort of flaws you actually see in real people or at least are excusable. The
only clear exception is the episode with the murderer where, for once, the
attempts at excusing the character miserably fails.
It is easy to point fingers and admonish people for their
faults, but when you get to know the entire story, the moral high ground is a
far more shaky place and who is to be the judge? That seems to be the general
message. Kieslowski is not passing judgement either, he is merely challenging
our prejudices on what is good and right and points out that we are all
prisoners in this, sometimes miserable, thing, called life.
The pervading melancholy makes this not a happy watch. I
could only deal with so much misery at the time, but there are differences
between the episodes. This first episode is a gut-punch and had I not set out
to complete this, I might have stopped right there. Others are strangely uplifting
such as episode eight (my own favourite), which is a about ”bearing false
witness against thy neighbour”, but really is about forgiveness and reconciliation
with past decisions. There are people that appear utterly strange as the family
in episode seven or the young peeping Tom in episode six, but the disgust morphs
into reluctant understanding of these people and that their “crime” is, if not
excusable, then understandable.
There are few works in the canon of cinema that deals as
intensively with the human condition as “Dekalog” and for that alone this is an
essential watch. I actually feel smarter from watching it and appreciate the experience.
This is also a window into a past world as Poland has changed a lot since 1988.
I am going to Warsaw tonight and I have half a mind to seek out the apartment
block where it all takes place. According to Google Maps it still exist. The
human questions examined be “Dekalog” will not disappear any time soon.






