Within Our Gates
It is easy
to be hard on ”Within our Gates”. Technically this is an awful film. I can find
tons of ways to deride this movie but that does not mean that it is not worth
seeing it.
Within our
Gates was the first black movie to be made, meaning it was made by
Afro-American, using Afro-Americans and likely for Afro-Americans. As such it
is an antidote to D.W. Griffith “Birth of a Nation” with the notable difference
that “Birth of a Nation” was technically ahead of its time while “Within our
Gates” is technically primitive.
I imaging a
bunch of guys saying: Hey, why don’t we make a movie? How difficult can it be? Then
we can tell OUR story. Man, that could be soo cool.
Then they
gather friends and family and dig up a camera from somewhere and start
shooting.
They do
have a story. Actually several stories, which to some extend interconnect. And
it is also a good story, relevant and touching. They just sort of skipped the
entire script part. There is a woman leaving the north to go down to the south
where there is a school chaired by a doctor who is struggling to keep it
afloat. The woman returns back north to raise money for the school. Other sub
plots involve the woman’s family and a black preacher who is supporting the
white elite keeping the blacks submissive.
It is a
good story with lots of good and interesting points. Unfortunately it is told by
showing people talking in front of a static camera and then driving the story
forward using lots of inter-titles. That means that the story does not catch at
all. Some scenes are way too long, while some are rushed. Some does not tell
anything and without the inter-titles those scenes would just be really
confusing.
The acting
is not really acting because acting implies that you are actually trying to
act. In fact it reminds me of the home videos we would do as children with
borrowed equipment.
In “Birth
of a Nation” I wished there was a worthwhile story to apply their superior technique
on. With “Within our Gates” I wished they had adequate technique to apply on
their superior story.
As it is it
is (again) one of those movies I am glad to have seen but not really inclined
to watch again.