Bull Durham
I do not know the first thing about baseball. For one, I was
born and live on the wrong continent for that sport and secondly, any attempt
at grasping it has hit a wall, every time. The rules, the lingo, the names and the
concepts, it is all nonsense to me. That is not unique for baseball, I feel the
same way for many other sports. American football is an even darker zone. In
the case of “Bull Durham” this is a problem because this movie is all about
baseball.
Most sports movies are watchable despite the mumbo-jumbo of the
sport in question, because they are built on a framework story that goes beyond
the particular sport. Here it is a mentorship story (I think). A team called
Durham Bulls is playing lousy, but has a talented player, a pitcher I learned
it is called, by the name Ebby Calvin LaLoosh (Tim Robbins). As this talent is
hiding, the owners (?) of the team has found an older player called Lawrence
"Crash" Davis (Kevin Costner) to mentor Ebby. Ebby is not terribly
smart and Crash is a bitter man who (I think) did not quite make it, so they
are hitting it well.
The love interest of the movie is Annie Savoy (Susan
Sarandon) who is some sort of baseball groupie. I did not understand half the
things she said, but understood she takes on a new player as lover each season
and this one it is either Ebby or Crash. A good chunk of the movie is devoted to
this triangle. There is also another girl, Millie (Jenny Robertson), who is
less selective who on the team she takes to bed.
Crash’s methods are of course unorthodox, but they work and
Ebby, now sporting the name “Nuke” makes it to a big team, which means there is
no real need for Crash anymore.
Of course, a lot more happens but I did not understand much
of that. The ratio of sports stuff to general stuff is very high here, much
higher than normal, which likely pleases fans of the sport to no end, but is
frustrating to the rest of us. There is an underlying celebration of fandom to
the sport, of people who go all in for it, even if they are no good at it or
just spectators. In that sense, it could have been any other sport, now it just
happened to be baseball. The characters hang so much of their life, purpose and
interest up on the sport and it is as if the movie asks if this is a fantastic
thing or perhaps a bit problematic.
I feel it is difficult to discuss the movie, because I am
obviously missing so much of it. The decision of Annie to go with Nuke or Crash
seems tied to their endeavours in the games... maybe. I sense she sees them as
her price, as if she is winning something by having a successful player under
her control and, following that, it annoys her no end when they are not
complying with her. Maybe that is a lesson to her, maybe she needs to grow up or
find something in her life that is less connected to baseball.
Same thing with Crash. The bitterness he feels could be
linked to almost making it, but it could also be that he feels manipulated and
powerless to avoid or resist the control of other people. The team owners and
Annie may here be the same thing, but I could be entirely wrong. In the end,
certainly, Crash and Annie seem to find a kindred spirit in each other.
I have no idea if this is a good sports movie. I will let fans
of the sport decide that. Susan Sarandon is usually watchable and Costner is...
well a matter of taste. I cannot say he is doing anything wrong here. “Bull
Durham” is not a movie I remember from my youth, and I would not be surprised
if it was never released to cinemas in Europe. Baseball is practically
non-existent here. I did not feel much smarter watching it, but I am clearly
not the target audience.

I was genuinely curious about what your reaction to this would be. This is a quintessentially American movie in so many ways. Baseball is far less important in the U.S. now than it was, but when Bull Durham was made, it was absolutely a part of American DNA.
ReplyDeleteI won't attempt to explain baseball to you. It would take days. The baseball in this movie is fine--it's more about the relationships here and their relationship to the game than it is the game itself in a lot of ways, but I think you need to get baseball on a deep, lived-in level to really understand the movie.
The most important aspect regarding baseball seems to be something that you've grasped. The team in question is a minor league team, which means it's professional, but not at the highest level, and players can be moved up from this level to the highest (major league) level for a variety of reasons. The teams at these levels are affiliated with a specific major league team. These days, the Bulls are a part of the Tampa Bay Rays franchise, but when the movie was made, they were a step below the Atlanta Braves.
You know that feeling of showing up to a party where everybody have known each other since childhood, but you only met them last week? There is a language and shared memory that you are not part of. You can follow general themes, but everything is viewed through a context you are not part of. I think that is why locally based comedies rarely work, but tragedies, touching on something universal, speaks to us all.
DeleteWith Bull Durham, it felt I was crashing such a party. I am grateful for your attempt at explaining this to me, but even then I am left confused. I would not even begin to understand what it means to be one step below Atlanta Braves.
I'll see if I can explain what that means.
DeleteThe Tampa Bay Rays are a professional baseball team at the highest professional level--they're in the equivalent of the Premier League in British football. But unlike British football, where teams can move from one league to the next, the Rays are always in Major League Baseball--the team is always in the same place.
The Durham Bulls are what are called a minor league team, and they are affiliated with a team in the Major League. While the teams can't move from one league to the next, players can. If someone on the Rays is hurt, a player can be moved up from the Durham Bulls to become a new player for the Rays--but only the Rays. Bulls players can't be called up to other teams because they are a part of essentially the same company as the Rays. Years ago, the Bulls had that relationship with the Braves, but now they are a part of the Rays organization.
The Bulls are what is called a AAA team, which means that players moving up from that level go to the highest level of professional baseball. Below them is AA, then High A, then A, then Rookie teams. Every major league team has this collection of teams below them.
Yes, there's a lot more and it gets more complicated than just that, but hopefully that makes sense--think of it as a hierarchy of teams--or 30 hierarchies, since there are 30 organizations like this, the Rays being one of them.
Ah, ok, that makes sense. It is a curious system and I would not have guessed. Thank you, Steve.
DeleteThis is a great baseball movie and I can understand why you might not get it since baseball is kind of foreign to Europeans as with us Americans towards cricket. Still, this is a movie that fans of the game love. Much of it does feel real including the scene where everyone is trying to figure out a wedding present to get as well as what I still think is the worst call ever. That motherfucker still never touched home plate. What a cocksucking call!
ReplyDeleteTo be fair, there are many sports I do not understand, so it is nothing against baseball. I trust that this is a real depiction of fandom and that is also what I got out of it. You do not need to understand the rules to recognize people getting excited.
Delete