Chok
Roman
Polanski’s first movie on the List, yay!
While most
of the directors on the List so far are gone by now, Roman Polanski is still around,
well, in Europe at least, and for me that marks the beginning of the current
era. Which of course is a lot of bull because Polanski has been around so long
that his career spans a whole series of eras. Yet, it still feels special to
me.
I tend to
like Roman Polanski’s movies and being presented with one I had never seen nor
even heard of made me very excited. I was looking forward to this movie like a
child for Christmas. Fortunately, I was not disappointed.
That was
not apparent from the opening of the movie, though. Pretty Catherine Deneuve as
Carol Ledoux walks around the streets of London, goes to work in a beauty
parlor and sits around at home with her sister Helen (Yvonne Furneaux). Pretty
boring. Slowly, though, we start to feel something is wrong. Carol is suited by
a guy called Colin (John Fraser) who is hitting quite hard on her, but Carol
pushes him off. In fact, she seems to be repulsed by men in general, especially
Helen’s boyfriend Michael (Ian Hendry). That is actually understandable, all
the men in the movie are dicks, or at least acts like it. So, at this point I
do understand why she abhors these guys.
Then Helen
and Michael leave for a holiday in Italy and things start to go downhill fast
for Carol. Her weirdness becomes more than just a quirk. At times she is
catatonic, then she hallucinates, walls are cracking, there is an imagined man
raping her in her bed and arms from the walls are grapping for her. She
isolates herself in her apartment, which becomes a metaphor for her mental
prison as are the rotting rabbit and the vegetables in the kitchen. By the time
her boyfriend and the landlord show up she has gone completely bananas.
This works
beautifully. Carols decent into madness is very convincing. We get a view in on
her hallucinations and they are frightening. There are very effective jump scares
(hey, I was jumping in my seat, but I am also an easy victim) and Carol’s nightmare
gets as rotten and revolting as the dead rabbit in the kitchen. It is a simple
story, but it is done extremely effectively.
Catherine
Deneuve is miles away from the happy girl in “The Umbrellas of Cherbourg” and
is every bit the insane girl. She is sweet and innocent in the beginning, catatonic
with a completely empty look and wild berserker at times. Her eyes scream fear
or vacancy and she seems to have become a model for a girl-doll-turned-lunatic-murderess.
I am sure this will influence my impression of Deneuve in the movies to come.
The cinematography
is also outstanding. It is black and white, yes, but it actually works to the
advantage here. Madness apparently requires these black and white tones. The
London Carol walks around in is so natural and realistic and completely offsets
the mad visions in the apartment, where the special effects department has been
busy.
There is in
fact very little negative I can say about this movie. Do we need to know more
about Carol and her background, why she is ill? Not really. It is
impressionistic. We learn a lot about her just from looking at her and
listening to her. An actual explanation would just be in the way. Is it too
sensational, a pretty girl turned crazy? Maybe, but does that matter? Is it not
because she is a pretty little thing that it seems even more powerful. The men
never see her fragile mind, they only see a pretty face and sexy legs and so
her isolation is complete.
I can only
recommend “Repulsion”. It may be the best movie in 1965 for me. Certainly the
most effective. Go watch it! Now!
I too love this. Catherine Deneuve is wonderful as she descends into madness. As you say, it feels gradual, which really draws you in. I liked that it didn't give a reason as it added to the mystery of her experience instead of making it follow a prescripted path.
ReplyDeleteOne of the those films that shows the brilliance of black-and-white cinematography as well!
Indeed. If we had gotten a lot of explanation we would not have felt so desoriented and thus sharing her experience. As it is we were drawn in very effectively.
DeleteIt's such an upsetting movie.
ReplyDeleteSay what you will about Polanski, the apartment trilogy is great all the way through. I'm prone to liking Rosemary's Baby more than the others and The Tenant less than the others. Your mileage may vary.
I do remember Rosemary's Baby allthough it is many years ago since I saw it, but I do remember it being interesting. I am looking forward to that rewatch.
DeleteI tend to like Polanski and I hope the List will feature a lot of his movies.