India Song
The best
way to introduce the movie “India Song”, I suppose, is to try to describe it.
From start
to finish there is a narration. This is mostly a dialogue, but with several
different voices. Always the tone is as if the voices are reading poetry, slow,
deliberate and obscure. In small bites the narration is well understood, but it
also evades focus, so you soon loose track of what the dialogue is about. Or at
least I did. There are thematic jumps, abrupt sentences, unanswered questions
and sentences that seem to require a background story that is not shared with
us. Most of all, there is little connection, if any, to the pictures we are
watching.
Certain
words are repeated. Something about vice-consuls, embassies, Lahore, Calcutta,
lepers, tennis courts. All things that lead me to believe this is all about
some members of the diplomatic corps in South Asia in the 1930’ies.
The
pictures contain slow, often static people who never open their mouths. There
is a woman (Delphine Seyrig, who seems to have made a career out of doing
obscure movies) who is sometimes do slow dances with different men. Mostly
though, these men are just standing or walking slowly around. The setting is a French
mansion, and I am guessing we are to believe it is located in India.
Often the
dialogue is combined or broken by music, including a recurrent theme that seems
to be referred to as India Song.
Yeah…
This is
about as pretentious as it gets. Very arty and stylized. So pretentious that it
is almost a joke on itself. When somebody started shouting, I had to laugh, it
was just so too much. Still, most of the time it is just plain boring because
the narration keeps eluding me and I have no idea what is going on.
There is a
trance like quality to the images and the voices that certainly makes it a
special movie to watch and that does invoke a sense of dreaming and of something
lost in the past as if the pictures are merely memories. It is an undeniable
quality, but two hours of this is a long time to drive a point.
I did like
the score though. It matches the trance-like images very well, especially that
recurrent theme and there were periods where I was just listening to that and
not worrying too much about the imagery or the narration.
Apparently,
this movie is par for the course for director and writer Maguerite Duras and it
certainly inherits something from the French art scene of the early sixties. I
guess if you dig “Last Year in Marienbad” you will get a kick out of “India
Song”.
Seeing “India
Song” as a movie is probably wrong. It is an art installation like Jeanne
Dielmann, but less successful, I think. It gets a little too impressed with its
own artiness and so verges on being a mockery.
Still, not
a movie I will soon forget, for better or worse.
Oh, I hated this movie so much. And if memory serves, I compared it to Jeanne Dielmann as well.
ReplyDeleteYes, you did. Delphine Seyrig seems to be synonymous with obscure movies. I was thinking of you watching this movie, betting you would be disgusted.
Delete